September 9, 2024
Quebec, Canada and the quandary of nationhood
Constructing national identities is and will always be a complex process.
Constructing national identities is and will always be a complex process.

In her Gazette column on Tuesday, Lise Ravary disagrees with the idea that a constitutional recognition of Quebec as a nation risks denying the existence of the Canadian nation. Ravary is referring to my criticism of a 2017 Quebec Liberal Party policy statement that called for recognition of Canada as a plurinational or European-style multi-national federation. She believes that the policy statement was “well thought out.”

I beg to differ as the proposed multinational vision of Canada lacks clarity. Indeed, the ambiguous use of the term nation enables the policy statement’s authors to insist that Quebec is a nation all the while denying that Canada is. Apart from the occasional reference to Canada as a federation, the policy statement describes the country as a stage, a space, a political project, a platform and/or a framework.

Paradoxically, while not recognizing the Canadian nation the same policy statement calls for nation to nation dialogue between the Quebec nation and its counterpart or equivalent English Canadian or “rest of Canada” nation. This vision of Canada leaves many unresolved issues about the number of nations both outside and within Quebec. For example, it is estimated that there are more than 60 First Nations across Canada. The policy statement offers no model of governance to accommodate the multiple nations that may seek constitutional recognition.

Perhaps the key characteristic of the Quebec nation is that French is its common language. English is therefore seen as the common language in the nation in the rest of Canada, which explains the reference to it as the English-Canadian nation. But if language is to be the basis for being conferred the status of nation then there is most certainly an English-Canadian nation within Quebec. And it might be legitimate for Acadians or other francophone minorities outside Quebec to describe themselves as nations. Indeed if Canada is to be regarded as a multi-national federation, Quebec can also be described as a nation of nations given the presence of so many First Nations within the territory.

[…]

See Also:

(1) Here’s what Quebec’s values test accomplishes

Loading