May 14, 2025
The Conservatives need a new leader. Now
The Conservatives need a better leader than Scheer is willing or able to be, and the Canadian people deserve an effectively led Opposition.
The Conservatives need a better leader than Scheer is willing or able to be, and the Canadian people deserve an effectively led Opposition.

This time, Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer didn’t miss an empty net. He put the puck in. Sadly, the period was already over, and it had been for a week.

That hockey analogy is riffing off one made by Peter MacKay, not long after last year’s election. The Conservatives were gifted just about every imaginable gift by the Liberals — remember the brownface pictures? — and still flopped. A popular vote win was wasted on a campaign that completely fizzled in Quebec and Ontario, particularly in the crucial Greater Toronto Area ridings. It was a pathetic performance against a self-destructing opponent. MacKay’s comment was bang on — the net was empty and all the Tories had to do was glide the puck in. But they couldn’t do it.

Much of the blame was assigned to Scheer — he of regrettably limited charisma, minimal gift for campaigning, a tin ear for communications and a few mid-campaign surprises of his own. He tried to hang on for a couple awkward months before finally agreeing in December to quit, saying he simply didn’t have the heart to continue any longer with the kind of commitment a leader required. He and the party agreed he’d stay on until a new leader was selected. But then the pandemic hit and the Conservative leadership race was put on hold. This has left the official Opposition with a leader who’s already agreed to quit because his heart isn’t in it anymore — and it shows.

[…]